Le Pays De France - Hamas attacks horrific but unlike Holocaust: Yad Vashem chairman

Dani Dayan, chairman of Jerusalem's Yad Vashem memorial centre, stressed that the attack, although appalling, was fundamentally different from Nazi Germany's mass murder of six million Jews.

"I do not accept the simplistic comparison with the Holocaust even if there are similarities in the genocidal intentions, sadism and barbarism of Hamas," Dayan told AFP.

"The crimes that took place on October 7 are on the same level as Nazi crimes, but they are not the Shoah," said the former Israeli diplomat, using another term for the Holocaust.

Dayan said he understood the revulsion and dark echoes triggered by the Hamas attack that Israeli officials say killed at least 1,200 people, mostly civilians, and saw about 240 taken hostage.

"For any Jew who has heard the stories of families putting their hands over a baby's mouth to stop it from crying, the association of ideas is obvious. We have all thought about it," he said.

Aside from the scale of the events, Dayan pointed to the fact that Jews today -- unlike many during World War II -- are far from defenceless victims, and that the State of Israel has hit back hard.

"We cannot compare it with the period of the Holocaust because there is an army here which is fighting and making Hamas pay the price," he said.

Israel has relentlessly bombarded the Gaza Strip and according to the besieged territory's Hamas-run government killed more than 14,000 Palestinians, most of them women and children.

A temporary respite was in sight as Israel and Hamas have agreed a truce of four days and an exchange of some hostages and Palestinian prisoners, although Israel has maintained it will "destroy" Hamas.

- 'Beheadings, rapes, shootings' -

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and others have repeatedly called the Hamas attacks the worst against Jews since the Holocaust -- but Dayan warns against such parallels.

Early on, Israel's ambassador to the United Nations, Gilad Erdan, pinned a yellow star to his chest, insisting he would wear it "with pride" as long as the Security Council did not condemn the Hamas "atrocities".

"Some of you have learned nothing in the past 80 years," Erdan said.

"Just like my grandparents, and the grandparents of millions of Jews, from now on my team and I will wear yellow stars," he said.

Dayan at the time wrote in a Hebrew-language post on social media platform X, formerly Twitter, that "this act disgraces the victims of the Holocaust as well as the State of Israel".

"The yellow star symbolises the helplessness of the Jewish people and their being at the mercy of others... Today we will fasten to our lapel a blue and white flag, not a yellow star."

Dayan said he was even more irritated by comments from UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres, who said the Hamas attacks "did not happen in a vacuum", referring to the Palestinians' long plight.

"I asked him what context could explain the beheading of children, rapes or shootings of young people at a music festival," Dayan said.

- 'The fear has returned' -

Yad Vashem, the World Holocaust Remembrance Center, was established in 1953, five years after the creation of Israel.

Since October 7, it has cancelled educational seminars and turned some spaces into classrooms for 400 students evacuated from southern Israel.

It was necessary, said Dayan, to "adapt the premises" to the needs of the children displaced by the attacks or evacuated amid the Gaza war.

"We removed the photos from the walls so as not to add trauma to trauma," he said.

The memorial centre itself counts some of its own staff among the victims.

Polish-born Israeli historian Alex Dancyg, 75, who worked at Yad Vashem, was last seen at the Nir Oz kibbutz and is feared to be among the hostages, as is one of the guides, Liat Atzili.

A fellow educator, Shlomo Balsam, also rejected likening October 7 to the Shoah, even as he said "I hear survivors say that it takes them back to that time".

Balsam is honorary president of Aloumim, an Israeli organisation for Holocaust survivors who were hiding in France during the war.

Some members, now very old, met at Yad Vashem and discussed both their childhood memories and their fears for the hostages, and for grandchildren serving as soldiers in Gaza.

"Children held hostage alone in Gaza are like us when we were abandoned alone during the war," said one octogenarian, Meira Bursztejn-Barer.

Berthe Badehi, 91, who survived the war hiding in a farmer's house, said the fear she felt at the time had returned.

This time around, she said determinedly, "we will emerge victorious".

(R.Dupont--LPdF)